Replacement Cost vs Actual Cash Value for SC Homeowners

I'm Vic Morgano, a licensed South Carolina agent and owner of The Morgano Agency here in Greenville since 1998, and the question I answer most is Replacement Cost vs Actual Cash Value. Replacement Cost Value (RCV) pays the full cost to rebuild a South Carolina home or replace items as new. Actual Cash Value (ACV) pays replacement cost minus depreciation, which can run 30 to 70 percent less on older roofs and worn personal property. In our Greenville office we see this gap surprise people most after a hailstorm rolls through the Upstate. Most standard HO-3 policies in SC put RCV on the dwelling and ACV on personal property unless an RCV endorsement gets added, so we read every declarations page line by line before a client signs.

Reviewed by Vic Morgano, founder and licensed South Carolina insurance agent (SC insurance license #612823), The Morgano Agency Inc. Serving Greenville and the Upstate since 1998. Last updated July 01, 2026.

What is the difference between RCV and ACV in SC homeowners?

Replacement Cost Value (RCV) pays to rebuild or replace damaged property as new, with nothing subtracted for age or wear. Actual Cash Value (ACV) pays the replacement cost minus depreciation. Here is how I explain it to clients off Augusta Road and out in Simpsonville: on a 15-year-old roof, ACV may pay 50 to 70 percent less than RCV after a hail claim, because the carrier knocks off the years of life that roof already used up. RCV is the stronger coverage but costs 5 to 15 percent more in premium, and most mortgage lenders here require RCV on the dwelling anyway. The SC DOI oversees how these settlements work in our state.

Does SC homeowners insurance use RCV or ACV on the dwelling?

Most standard HO-3 policies in South Carolina use Replacement Cost Value (RCV) on the dwelling, paying to rebuild as new without depreciation, as long as the coverage limit stays at least 80 percent of estimated replacement cost. That 80 percent figure is the coinsurance clause, and it trips up a lot of homeowners in older Greenville neighborhoods like North Main and the West End where rebuild costs climbed faster than their limits. Homes with 20-plus year roofs may carry an ACV roof endorsement that pays only depreciated value on roof claims. Before we bind anything in our Greenville office, we confirm the dwelling settlement type in writing so a Simpsonville or Travelers Rest client is never guessing. The SC DOI publishes consumer guides on these clauses.

Should I get RCV or ACV on personal property in SC?

I steer almost every family toward Replacement Cost Value (RCV) on personal property. It is the better coverage and usually costs only 5 to 10 percent more in premium. ACV pays a depreciated amount on older electronics, furniture, and clothing, often 40 to 70 percent less than what it costs to replace those things as new. Most Upstate clients we help, especially families near Furman or the folks working over at the Michelin and Prisma Health campuses with newer TVs, appliances, and kids' gear, come out ahead with RCV. The math is easy when you see what a depreciated check actually buys you at the store. The Insurance Information Institute walks through the same comparison.

What is the SC roof ACV clause?

Many SC homeowners carriers apply an Actual Cash Value (ACV) settlement to roofs older than 10 to 15 years, paying only the depreciated value of the damaged roof material instead of full replacement cost. For a 20-year-old 3-tab shingle roof, ACV might pay 30 to 50 percent of replacement cost. This matters in the Upstate because the spring and summer storms that sweep down from the Blue Ridge toward Greer and Taylors drop hail that finds every tired roof in Greenville County. If your roof has some age on it, confirm whether your policy carries this endorsement and budget for the out-of-pocket gap before a storm forces the question. The SC DOI can confirm what your carrier filed.

Can I switch from ACV to RCV in SC homeowners?

Yes. Most South Carolina carriers let homeowners switch from ACV to RCV on personal property at renewal, usually raising premium 5 to 10 percent. RCV on the dwelling is generally automatic on HO-3 policies as long as coverage meets the 80 percent coinsurance threshold. In our Greenville office we review each homeowner's settlement type, from Pelham Road to downtown, and recommend the upgrade whenever the small premium bump is worth the protection. If you want a second set of eyes on your current policy, see our Greenville homeowners insurance page or call the office and we will read your declarations with you.

Get an Insurance Quote in Greenville, SC